All of the enchants take a long time to get. Whale enchants take hours to get of just sitting at your computer and clicking not putting anything into your island. I think that the tear of dust shouldn't matter because if you spend at least 3 hour sitting and clicking just for a chance of getting dust just seem like a huge waste of time. I would say that all of the enchants should be less expensive but that's already happened so I think that the dust from the crab enchants should be able to be put on whale and shark books. The time and odds of the whale/shark books is way to much. this seems like an easy change and it would be really nice for all players. Thank you for your time.